Jump to content

Open/closed enrollment, transfers, recruiting….Help me UNDERSTAND?

PNG4LIFE91

By PNG4LIFE91
in High School Football

 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 219
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

WOSdrummer99
WOSdrummer99

Louisiana solved that problem. Open districts go to a different playoff bracket. Let them compete against others that aren't homegrown talent. It may be complicated but that's above my pay grade. I on

oldschool2
oldschool2

Fine.. just make every single transfer sit a year for varsity competition.  Regardless of the reason.   That should show who's actually changing schools for academic reasons. 

CS.
CS.

I actually provided facts to back my statements but you didn't want to hear them.  You are tone deaf.  No one will convince you otherwise that your opinion is just biased based on personal feelings an

89Falcon

89Falcon

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 2:26 PM, Coach_Izzy said:

The text messages he sent to kids said nothing about them transferring to NS…this issue was brought about from a piss poor coach (Delaney HC) who had it out for NS! I’ve told this story plenty of times. Learn the facts big dog

Expand  

Being that you are an arbiter of facts, Is it a “fact” that the coach received a “multi year UIL ban”? Did UIL issue the ban for non-UIL infractions? 
 

Setx fan

Setx fan

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 4:11 PM, Coach_Izzy said:

Well PNG folks y’all better hope this law doesn’t  get passed lol 

 

This is the hidden content, please

Expand  

Why are you going all out your way to support schools getting a large amount of transfers being able to compete against schools mostly consisting of homegrown talent? It wouldn't make sense to you for those schools to compete against other schools who are doing the same? Seems like you don't have a good sense of fairness. 

SmashMouth

SmashMouth

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 1:43 AM, Coach_Izzy said:

 

A coach who hadn’t been employed at NS for even a full year & was running an outside recruiting service on his own. 

NS has been dominating for 20+ years and never got hit with a recruiting violation lol please stop reaching. 

Expand  

It's not a reach, it happened, and I wasn't speaking specifically of North Shore. Other sanctions have been handed down to other schools too. 

SmashMouth

SmashMouth

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 3:24 PM, Coach_Izzy said:

My statement wasn’t referring to anything you posted…simply stating to you the dumb sh*t other posters were posting on here which was indeed stupid & racist. Maybe you aren’t reading the same things as me lol

Expand  

There's only one poster with the stupid racist crap (maybe two). Don't paint the rest of that with that brush. 

 

Coach_Izzy

Coach_Izzy

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 4:30 PM, 89Falcon said:

Being that you are an arbiter of facts, Is it a “fact” that the coach received a “multi year UIL ban”? Did UIL issue the ban for non-UIL infractions? 
 

Expand  

It is also a fact that NS has never been sanctioned for such violations before this coached arrived…you missed my entire point lol

Coach_Izzy

Coach_Izzy

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 4:56 PM, Setx fan said:

Why are you going all out your way to support schools getting a large amount of transfers being able to compete against schools mostly consisting of homegrown talent? It wouldn't make sense to you for those schools to compete against other schools who are doing the same? Seems like you don't have a good sense of fairness. 

Expand  

Because I’ve been apart of it & understand what actually goes on. Y’all are discrediting these schools & coaches success and the programs they’ve built. Accusing them of cheating with no facts to back your statements.

 Is it these schools fault that kids want to be apart of the success these programs have created? Are they supposed to shut the door on these kids? Is it the district’s fault that they value athletics & open their doors to anyone who wants to attend school there.
 

Tell all the districts who aren’t open enrollment to make their districts open enrollment & let’s see how many power 5 kids are knocking the doors down to attend school there like these other programs. No need to wine & complain about it…kids are transferring left & right at the HS and college level deal with it. Simple 

Right99JOH

Right99JOH

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 6:31 PM, Coach_Izzy said:

Because I’ve been apart of it & understand what actually goes on. Y’all are discrediting these schools & coaches success and the programs they’ve built. Accusing them of cheating with no facts to back your statements.

 Is it these schools fault that kids want to be apart of the success these programs have created? Are they supposed to shut the door on these kids? Is it the district’s fault that they value athletics & open their doors to anyone who wants to attend school there.
 

Tell all the districts who aren’t open enrollment to make their districts open enrollment & let’s see how many power 5 kids are knocking the doors down to attend school there like these other programs. No need to wine & complain about it…kids are transferring left & right at the HS and college level deal with it. Simple 

Expand  

Again, everyone save yourself the time... you can't have a convo, back-n-forth with this guy cause his word is the end all be all.  He's coached at every high-profile school in the state and knows how each and every program and district operates.  

You say night he's going to say day.  You say white he's going to say black.

CS.

CS.

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 6:31 PM, Coach_Izzy said:

Because I’ve been apart of it & understand what actually goes on. Y’all are discrediting these schools & coaches success and the programs they’ve built. Accusing them of cheating with no facts to back your statements.

 Is it these schools fault that kids want to be apart of the success these programs have created? Are they supposed to shut the door on these kids? Is it the district’s fault that they value athletics & open their doors to anyone who wants to attend school there.
 

Tell all the districts who aren’t open enrollment to make their districts open enrollment & let’s see how many power 5 kids are knocking the doors down to attend school there like these other programs. No need to wine & complain about it…kids are transferring left & right at the HS and college level deal with it. Simple 

Expand  

I actually provided facts to back my statements but you didn't want to hear them.  You are tone deaf.  No one will convince you otherwise that your opinion is just biased based on personal feelings and experience.  

Also, you seem to ignore that the original suggestions weren't to "close the door on them" but rather ask them to play up a level or two to make it more fair throughout the entire field of teams. 

no. what you want is for them to stack teams every year and win state.  then sit there and beat your chest that the coaches "built something"  

You know who built something?  Woodville.  PNG.  etc.  That is building something.  

89Falcon

89Falcon

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 7:19 PM, CS. said:

I actually provided facts to back my statements but you didn't want to hear them.  You are tone deaf.  No one will convince you otherwise that your opinion is just biased based on personal feelings and experience.  

Also, you seem to ignore that the original suggestions weren't to "close the door on them" but rather ask them to play up a level or two to make it more fair throughout the entire field of teams. 

no. what you want is for them to stack teams every year and win state.  then sit there and beat your chest that the coaches "built something"  

You know who built something?  Woodville.  PNG.  etc.  That is building something.  

Expand  

His definition of “fact” is: “whatever thought arrives in his mind”. Anything he doesn’t like is called: “not a fact”. 
 

Example: The UIL issuing a multi year ban to a NS coach is not considered a fact, even though it happened and is settled record. 

Rez

Rez

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 3:36 PM, oldschool2 said:

Fine.. just make every single transfer sit a year for varsity competition.  Regardless of the reason.  

That should show who's actually changing schools for academic reasons. 

Expand  

That’s my solution - It would solve 90 percent of the problems and wouldn’t require policing the reasons. 

bullets13

bullets13

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 8:19 PM, 89Falcon said:

There are reasons other than academic and athletic that kids switch schools. Most moves are not related to either of those but are the result of changing family situations.

Expand  

unfortunate for those kids but would still benefit texas high school sports as a whole. I think there could be some very cut and dry requirements (a divorce or death certificate, for example) that would allow for a transfer without sitting out. Moving apartments across town to be closer to the better football team and saying you moved because the apt was cheaper just wouldn't be one.

89Falcon

89Falcon

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 8:31 PM, bullets13 said:

unfortunate for those kids but would still benefit texas high school sports as a whole. I think there could be some very cut and dry requirements (a divorce or death certificate, for example) that would allow for a transfer without sitting out. Moving apartments across town to be closer to the better football team and saying you moved because the apt was cheaper just wouldn't be one.

Expand  

It is usually job related. 

89Falcon

89Falcon

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 11:01 PM, bullets13 said:

Or at least “job related.” Dad takes a new coaching job there… allow it. Dad transfers from the Arlington McDonald’s to the one in South Oak Cliff for no reason, maybe not.  

Expand  

People move all the time for a variety of reasons. The overwhelming majority of people in the state do not work for schools but still experience job changes and frequently have corresponding moves. Many of them have kids that go with them.

The UIL cannot discriminate against kids because their families take new jobs. It is not constitutionally possible to have a "blanket" and "no exception" sit out for one year from sports.

OlDawg

OlDawg

Posted
Posted
  On 12/18/2024 at 11:43 PM, 89Falcon said:

People move all the time for a variety of reasons. The overwhelming majority of people in the state do not work for schools but still experience job changes and frequently have corresponding moves. Many of them have kids that go with them.

The UIL cannot discriminate against kids because their families take new jobs. It is not constitutionally possible to have a "blanket" and "no exception" sit out for one year from sports.

Expand  

I agree with most of the points you’ve made. But, not sure on this one. Extracurricular participation isn’t guaranteed by the State. Only education at a public school. While the UIL has recently been ruled a pseudo government agency & thus protected from lawsuits, it doesn’t mean they—or their regulated activites— are a part of the ‘education of every child’ guarantee.

Prior to 1981, wasn’t there a blanket policy? I seem to remember there being one when I was in school in the 70’s.

89Falcon

89Falcon

Posted
Posted
  On 12/19/2024 at 1:41 AM, OlDawg said:

I agree with most of the points you’ve made. But, not sure on this one. Extracurricular participation isn’t guaranteed by the State. Only education at a public school. While the UIL has recently been ruled a pseudo government agency & thus protected from lawsuits, it doesn’t mean they—or their regulated activites— are a part of the ‘education of every child’ guarantee.

Prior to 1981, wasn’t there a blanket policy? I seem to remember there being one when I was in school in the 70’s.

Expand  

Discrimination against a kid for financial reasons goes well beyond state law. UIL cannot maintain a system that forces families to "stay down" or "not provide" for their families with the threat of not playing sports. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Member Statistics

    46,276
    Total Members
    1,837
    Most Online
    TheEagleHasLanded
    Newest Member
    TheEagleHasLanded
    Joined


×
×
  • Create New...