Which Astros bullpen would you rather have?

[bobcatfan]

Based on the early season struggles of the bullpen, i thought this would be an interesting question for yall.  Lidge, Qualls, Sarfate, was our best bullpen options at the end of last season and Ed Wade overhauled the team and gave us Valverde, Brocail, Geary (Villareal).  After what you've seen so far early in the season, are you wishing we had the old trio or are you still glad we got the new guys?

[Interested Observer]

I would rather have Lidge, Wheeler and Qualls

[cardinalcc]

I would rather have Lidge and Qualls at the end of the game instead of Valverde and Villareal/Brocail. There is just something with Valverde that I don't quite like.

[Ruckdad]

I think it is too early to decide this. 

[bullets13]

Brocail came on and got a save tonight... and Roy O finally looked pretty good!

[cardinals4life]

shouldn't have ever traded Wagner

[AJ25]

i think it's still a little early to decide. but i'd rather lidge if i had to choose. i'd rather wagner about ALL of them. lol

[WHBaseball14]

How bout the bullpen from the 2003 season the pitched the six pitcher no hitter? It had roy o-starting pitcher, brad lidge, kirk saarloos, pete munro, billy wagner, and octavio dotel. what about that?

[bullets13]

i think it's just something about wearing the Astros uniform.

Lidge's stats this year: 11 IP, 12 K, 0.00 ERA, 1.00 WHIP, 6/6 on saves

Qualls' stats this year: 14.2 IP, 14 K, 0.00 ERA, 0.89 WHIP, 1/2 on saves, 8/8 on holds

Wheeler's stats this year: 13 IP, 7 K, 1.38 ERA, 0.62 WHIP, 5/7 on holds

Valverde this year: 12 IP, 15 K, 7.50 ERA, 1.92 WHIP, 4/7 on saves

Valverde last year: 64.1 IP, 78 K, 2.66 ERA, .95 WHIP, 47/54 on saves

[Gabe]

Ahh the list grows of players who were Astros going on to become stars somewhere else.

[cardinals4life]

maybe just all those other teams have alot better coaching than the astros