Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Definitely uncalled for... but since we are discussing questionable plays.

How about the video for the hit across the middle?  Maybe we should upload that

and start a thread for taunting over an injured player.

Ill be waiting for the video.

Otherwise...

Leave it to the coaches from both teams.

Coach Smith has already proven that he can and will take action.

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 9:59 PM, Silsbee92 said:

Definitely uncalled for... but since we are discussing questionable plays.

How about the video for the hit across the middle?  Maybe we should upload that

and start a thread for taunting over an injured player.

Ill be waiting for the video.

Otherwise...

Leave it to the coaches from both teams.

Coach Smith has already proven that he can and will take action.

Expand  

Was the play you speak of a legal hit?  The hit in the above video is definitely not.   That's the kind of thing that's get's a player thrown out of a game.  Or worse.

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:12 PM, oldschool2 said:

Was the play you speak of a legal hit?  The hit in the above video is definitely not.   That's the kind of thing that's get's a player thrown out of a game.  Or worse.

Expand  

There is some question to that, it definitely wasn't of the same type as this one.  But definitely might have been a helmet to helmet or similar call. But, and I didn't see it myself, the taunting part would definitely be reason for a call.

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:12 PM, oldschool2 said:

Was the play you speak of a legal hit?  The hit in the above video is definitely not.   That's the kind of thing that's get's a player thrown out of a game.  Or worse.

Expand  

I didnt argue the missed call.  I agreed, if you read above.

Just making a point.  

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:17 PM, ST413 said:

There is some question to that, it definitely wasn't of the same type as this one.  But definitely might have been a helmet to helmet or similar call. But, and I didn't see it myself, the taunting part would definitely be reason for a call.

Expand  

That was just a big hit in which the player was fired up after. In the heat of the moment I could see where the ref could have thrown a flag, and I can also understand why he didn't too.

both players should be reprimanded, and as Silsbee92 stated, we'll see which coach makes the right decision. Hopefully both will.

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:21 PM, L-Train11 said:

That was just a big hit in which the player was fired up after. In the heat of the moment I could see where the ref could have thrown a flag, and I can also understand why he didn't too.

both players should be reprimanded, and as Silsbee92 stated, we'll see which coach makes the right decision. Hopefully both will.

Expand  

More than one.  Watch the video.

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:25 PM, L-Train11 said:

I've only seen one video that ended about a second after the hit. But I trust your judgement. I'm sure coaches are watching the film and evaluating the situation.

Expand  

Only video that has been posted is the obvious late hit.

We'll see if any others surface.  I myself, remain doubtful.

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:27 PM, Silsbee92 said:

Only video that has been posted is the obvious late hit.

We'll see if any others surface.  I myself, remain doubtful.

Expand  

Wow really ??? There is no comparison period !!!! I will promise you one thing the jasper players know who the young man is... I doubt very seriously the silsbee coach will punish the young man

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:34 PM, T-daddy said:

Wow really ??? There is no comparison period !!!! I will promise you one thing the jasper players know who the young man is... I doubt very seriously the silsbee coach will punish the young man

Expand  

I would be willing to bet that he does. Don't forget that silsbee suspended an all American in basketball last year. It's been done before on a much bigger scale.

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:34 PM, T-daddy said:

Wow really ??? There is no comparison period !!!! I will promise you one thing the jasper players know who the young man is... I doubt very seriously the silsbee coach will punish the young man

Expand  

1) No need to be upset.  We are not in disagreement on the act.

Just pointing out the obvious double standard.

And the fact that the above highlighted was said by you... says it all.  IF that is true, then the thinking is the same on both sides of the field.

2) Guess we'll see then on coaches decisions.  And I did say coaches, as in both teams.

 

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:38 PM, Silsbee92 said:

1) No need to be upset.  We are not in disagreement on the act.

Just pointing out the obvious double standard.

And the fact that the above highlighted was said by you... says it all.  IF that is true, then the thinking is the same on both sides of the field.

2) Guess we'll see then on coaches decisions.  And I did say coaches, as in both teams.

 

Expand  

Have not seen the play you speak of, but I don't see the comparison between taunting and a complete cheap shot.  There is no place for neither action in the game.  But these players learn from watching the trash talking in college and the pros.

Posted
  On 9/16/2017 at 10:43 PM, BS Wildcats said:

Have not seen the play you speak of, but I don't see the comparison between taunting and a complete cheap shot.  There is no place for neither action in the game.  But these players learn from watching the trash talking in college and the pros.

Expand  

The taunt was done after a big hit that knocked a silsbee player out of the game. He was taken out by ambulance. That's why it's being compared.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Member Statistics

    46,283
    Total Members
    1,837
    Most Online
    ben broussard
    Newest Member
    ben broussard
    Joined
×
×
  • Create New...