Jump to content

"Excessive celebration"


Guest octfeb

Recommended Posts

[quote name="octfeb" post="1068970" timestamp="1317320221"]
Can someone tell me, What constitutes and illegal motion of celebration when a ball carrier makes a touchdown? :-\
[/quote]

I've never heard of an illegal motion of celebration? But if you are talking about a personal foul (unsportsmanlike conduct), then its usually a judgement call. At least in high school in college anyway. The pros have more stringent guidelines (at least for my 'boys) but I won't get into that here. They usually let them get away with high fives or a hip jump, etc.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest UHCoog14
[quote name="octfeb" post="1068970" timestamp="1317320221"]
Can someone tell me, What constitutes and illegal motion of celebration when a ball carrier makes a touchdown? :-\
[/quote]

Never heard of such a penalty. Are you asking about the "excessive celebration" penalty?

That rule states that a player can not "draw attention to himself". That leaves a lot of room for interpretation.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name="octfeb" post="1068970" timestamp="1317320221"]
Can someone tell me, What constitutes and illegal motion of celebration when a ball carrier makes a touchdown? :-\
[/quote]
illegal motion can be 2 or more guys in motion at the snap, one or more guys never getting set for one second before the snap, more than 4 in the backfield which is actually a different signal but sometimes gets confused..celebration has been relaxed and is more of a judgement call this year. I can tell you on my crew we let the kids have fun, a little, but never taunt. Some other crews are less tolerant, others are probably more so.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name="GCMPats" post="1068980" timestamp="1317320977"]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068970#msg1068970 date=1317320221]
Can someone tell me, What constitutes and illegal motion of celebration when a ball carrier makes a touchdown? :-\
[/quote]

Never heard of such a penalty. Are you asking about the "excessive celebration" penalty?

That rule states that a player can not "draw attention to himself". That leaves a lot of room for interpretation.
[/quote] Yeah maybe thats what it is.... probably what it is... sorry wrong choice of wording  *sigh* one day i will get it LOL.. what would constitute excessive celebration?  anyones opinion..
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name="octfeb" post="1068983" timestamp="1317321249"]
[quote author=GCMPats link=topic=89013.msg1068980#msg1068980 date=1317320977]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068970#msg1068970 date=1317320221]
Can someone tell me, What constitutes and illegal motion of celebration when a ball carrier makes a touchdown? :-\
[/quote]

Never heard of such a penalty. Are you asking about the "excessive celebration" penalty?

That rule states that a player can not "draw attention to himself". That leaves a lot of room for interpretation.
[/quote] Yeah maybe thats what it is.... probably what it is... sorry wrong choice of wording  *sigh* one day i will get it LOL.. what would constitute excessive celebration? I anyones opinion..
[/quote]
For my crew excessive is a choregrapghed dance routine or some kind of NFL thing with the ball or if they don't quit when i tell them them to. Hi fives, chest bumps etc. are ok. Do it and get off the field. Nothing wrong with kids being happy. Don't belittle/taunt/show up an opponent though. That pulls yellow immediately.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name="teeboan" post="1068986" timestamp="1317321556"]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068983#msg1068983 date=1317321249]
[quote author=GCMPats link=topic=89013.msg1068980#msg1068980 date=1317320977]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068970#msg1068970 date=1317320221]
Can someone tell me, What constitutes and illegal motion of celebration when a ball carrier makes a touchdown? :-\
[/quote]

Never heard of such a penalty. Are you asking about the "excessive celebration" penalty?

That rule states that a player can not "draw attention to himself". That leaves a lot of room for interpretation.
[/quote] Yeah maybe thats what it is.... probably what it is... sorry wrong choice of wording  *sigh* one day i will get it LOL.. what would constitute excessive celebration? I anyones opinion..
[/quote]
For my crew excessive is a choregrapghed dance routine or some kind of NFL thing with the ball or if they don't quit when i tell them them to. Hi fives, chest bumps etc. are ok. Do it and get off the field. Nothing wrong with kids being happy. Don't belittle/taunt/show up an opponent though. That pulls yellow immediately.
[/quote]

Tee, I did the Billy White Shoes in the endzone one time after catching a td pass, no flag in the 70's but I should have received one for a bad imitation !!!  lol
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name="MrUmp1" post="1068988" timestamp="1317321844"]
[quote author=teeboan link=topic=89013.msg1068986#msg1068986 date=1317321556]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068983#msg1068983 date=1317321249]
[quote author=GCMPats link=topic=89013.msg1068980#msg1068980 date=1317320977]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068970#msg1068970 date=1317320221]
Can someone tell me, What constitutes and illegal motion of celebration when a ball carrier makes a touchdown? :-\
[/quote]

Never heard of such a penalty. Are you asking about the "excessive celebration" penalty?

That rule states that a player can not "draw attention to himself". That leaves a lot of room for interpretation.
[/quote] Yeah maybe thats what it is.... probably what it is... sorry wrong choice of wording  *sigh* one day i will get it LOL.. what would constitute excessive celebration? I anyones opinion..
[/quote]
For my crew excessive is a choregrapghed dance routine or some kind of NFL thing with the ball or if they don't quit when i tell them them to. Hi fives, chest bumps etc. are ok. Do it and get off the field. Nothing wrong with kids being happy. Don't belittle/taunt/show up an opponent though. That pulls yellow immediately.
[/quote]

Tee, I did the Billy White Shoes in the endzone one time after catching a td pass, no flag in the 70's but I should have received one for a bad imitation !!!  lol
[/quote]
He was probably laughing too hard. I know I would have been rolling!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name="teeboan" post="1068986" timestamp="1317321556"]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068983#msg1068983 date=1317321249]
[quote author=GCMPats link=topic=89013.msg1068980#msg1068980 date=1317320977]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068970#msg1068970 date=1317320221]
Can someone tell me, What constitutes and illegal motion of celebration when a ball carrier makes a touchdown? :-\
[/quote]

Never heard of such a penalty. Are you asking about the "excessive celebration" penalty?

That rule states that a player can not "draw attention to himself". That leaves a lot of room for interpretation.
[/quote] Yeah maybe thats what it is.... probably what it is... sorry wrong choice of wording  *sigh* one day i will get it LOL.. what would constitute excessive celebration? I anyones opinion..
[/quote]
For my crew excessive is a choregrapghed dance routine or some kind of NFL thing with the ball or if they don't quit when i tell them them to.
[b]Hi fives, chest bumps etc. are ok. Do it and get off the field. Nothing wrong with kids being happy.[/b] Don't belittle/taunt/show up an opponent though. That pulls yellow immediately.
[/quote] yeah I agree with that. sooo what about slamming the ball on the ground?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name="octfeb" post="1068994" timestamp="1317322289"]
[quote author=teeboan link=topic=89013.msg1068986#msg1068986 date=1317321556]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068983#msg1068983 date=1317321249]
[quote author=GCMPats link=topic=89013.msg1068980#msg1068980 date=1317320977]
[quote author=octfeb link=topic=89013.msg1068970#msg1068970 date=1317320221]
Can someone tell me, What constitutes and illegal motion of celebration when a ball carrier makes a touchdown? :-\
[/quote]

Never heard of such a penalty. Are you asking about the "excessive celebration" penalty?

That rule states that a player can not "draw attention to himself". That leaves a lot of room for interpretation.
[/quote] Yeah maybe thats what it is.... probably what it is... sorry wrong choice of wording  *sigh* one day i will get it LOL.. what would constitute excessive celebration? I anyones opinion..
[/quote]
For my crew excessive is a choregrapghed dance routine or some kind of NFL thing with the ball or if they don't quit when i tell them them to.
[b]Hi fives, chest bumps etc. are ok. Do it and get off the field. Nothing wrong with kids being happy.[/b] Don't belittle/taunt/show up an opponent though. That pulls yellow immediately.
[/quote] yeah I agree with that. sooo what about slamming the ball on the ground?
[/quote]
spiking the ball is a no no
Link to comment
Share on other sites

There should be an exception to this rule whenever a lineman scores a touchdown.  If a big boy gets in the endzone he should be allowed to break dance, moonwalk, stick the ball beneath his jersey and pretend he is giving birth, whatever his heart desires.

No issue with flagging qb's, rb's, or wr...just let the big man celebrate because he may not get another chance.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name="the_dude_abides" post="1069026" timestamp="1317325405"]
There should be an exception to this rule whenever a lineman scores a touchdown.  If a big boy gets in the endzone he should be allowed to break dance, moonwalk, stick the ball beneath his jersey and pretend he is giving birth, whatever his heart desires.

No issue with flagging qb's, rb's, or wr...just let the big man celebrate because he may not get another chance.
[/quote]



hahahahahah totally agree
Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name="the_dude_abides" post="1069026" timestamp="1317325405"]
There should be an exception to this rule whenever a lineman scores a touchdown.  If a big boy gets in the endzone he should be allowed to break dance, moonwalk, stick the ball beneath his jersey and pretend he is giving birth, whatever his heart desires.

No issue with flagging qb's, rb's, or wr...just let the big man celebrate because he may not get another chance.
[/quote]

Excellent point, Dude.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Member Statistics

    45,977
    Total Members
    1,837
    Most Online
    cfbswami
    Newest Member
    cfbswami
    Joined


  • Posts

    • We'll see. I don't trust us. 
    • Starting pitching has been shaky the last few weeks due to some injuries outside of Hagen Smith.  He goes tomorrow, so y’all should be fine 
    • Manchin may get it but any mention of the radical left that wanted to get rid of the filibuster and end almost 220 years of history because the Democrats are mad?  The House and Senate are obviously different legislative bodies with entirely different election processes and rules for a reason. The House can vote on laws with a simple majority vote. The Senate put rules in place that it would make it much tougher to pass laws. Laws should be difficult to pass. The Senate is often the holdup of the right and left. It takes 60 votes to break the filibuster so any law will almost certainly require agreement at least in part, from opposing sides of an issue. Because they can’t get laws passed, the radical left is like a baby having a tantrum and wants to change over 200 years of history and make it potentially ridiculously easy to pass laws. I have seen current poll maps and it is possible for the Republicans to sweep into complete power in November but by the tiniest margin. That would possibly mean that a single vote margin in both houses could enact what you might call the radical right laws. There would be nothing that the Democrats could do to stop any legislation whatsoever if the left (they are all radical, minus Manchin) got their filibuster rule changed.  That is where the current filibuster comes into play as any new law would require several Democrats to agree with the majority Republicans and vice versa.  Do you want the potential for your radical right to have free rein as the radical left wants by killing the filibuster or is the radical left just as (if not more) dangerous? Let’s see if we have a history in this area? Oh yeah, the Democrats changed the rules in the Senate to allow federal judges to not have to overcome the filibuster. Obama was not getting his federal judge nominations passed and being angry, they changed the rules instead of nominating more moderate justices. They were warned that it would come back to bite them. They didn’t care and chose the nuclear option to change the rules. Oops! Any guess how Trump got all of his Supreme Court nominees passed against strong Democrat opposition? The Democrats got rid of the filibuster for federal judges after another tantrum   So when you are so worried about the radical right, are you equally concerned in what the radical left is always doing by changing rules and history which were put into place just for situations like we are in? So while Manchin gets it, what about his other 50 colleagues (49 + Harris)?  What concerns you more, Abbott and Paxton or the Democrats who want to make it to where if the Republicans do take over, they can go wild… at least in your mind? 
    • MODS please remove that ISD twitter link! I had no idea it would copy the whole posting. I only highlighted the portion about the venue change. Sorry about that!
  • Topics

×
×
  • Create New...