I agree that it is a lot for you, but it is not a lot. Cut off numbers for this year in 2A is a difference of 115. (105-220) So, I think that they are comparable. Tell Big Sandy that 112 kids is a lot when they are running Nederland and others out of the gym... C'mon.
Don't say that football is different. 2A's routinely beat 3A's, 3A's routinely beat 4A's, etc, etc, etc.
Face it. The level of play/talent in Colmesneil is down. You got rid of a coach because he....lost. The next guy will lose too. And the one after that, and the one after that, and the one after that. Maybe in 30 years or so you will find a group that can be successful.